Quota blues
Apropos of the editorial, “Quota conundrum” (Sept 15), the founding fathers’ idea of reservation was like that of the crutches lent to a physically challenged person until his limbs grow up and he stands on his own legs. The time has come for a review of the entire policy on quotas. The quota based reservation policy, a part of the affirmative action, envisaged as a tool of egalitarianism now stands catapulted as a ‘prized booty’.
The common refrain of the protagonists of the Jat reservation is that when some other peasantry castes in Haryana already enjoy the benefits of the reservation, why the Jats should be deprived of the same? The remedy lies in not giving quotas to any such caste.
RAJENDER GOYAL, Advocate, Bahadurgarh
NOTE:-In the above write-up published in "The Tribune". I have been misquoted in certain material aspect in so far as the assertion "The remedy lies is not giving quotas to any such caste" is concerned. In fact, I had used the expression "The remedy lies in disentitling any of such caste to reap the fruits of the reservation, if found, that they do not qualify for it" in the original write-up sent to The Tribune for publication . The flawed paraphrasing has resulted into total misconstruction of my perspective on this count.
The original write-up sent to "The Tribune" is reproduced below:
Bandwagon of reservation
Apropos the editorial “Quota conundrum: Hooda again mishandles situation”, Sept 15, the Founding Fathers’ idea of reservation policy was like that of the crutches lent to a limbless person until his limbs grow up and he stands on his own legs. The time has come at such a pass, paradoxically, where we see that the erstwhile limbless person, now having fully grown-up limbs, does not want to let go of the borrowed crutches, and the inherently able-bodied person has started clamouring for the crutches. The quota based reservation policy- a part of the affirmative action- envisaged as a tool of egalitarianism now stands catapulted as a ‘prized booty’. The common refrain of the protagonists of the jat reservation is that some other peasantry castes in Haryana already enjoy the benefits of the reservation, then, why jat should not be? Two wrongs do not make a right they constitute a plumb blunder. The remedy lies in disentitling any of such caste to reap the fruits of the reservation, if found, that they do not qualify for it. Be that as it may be, we must be alive to the hard fact that reservation is a state’s charity and it is highly unbecoming of any self-respecting person to live off anybody’s alms unless it is not at all possible to stand on one's own legs due to some insurmountable present or historical reasons.
RAJENDER GOYAL, Advocate
Bahadurgarh
Posts
No comments:
Post a Comment